➡I accidentally bought Balut eggs: 2 live ducks! Now a Chat Thread!

Yeah, sorry, it kinda blurred together/rambled. I’m going to try to address your addresses lol

  • I don’t think that’s necessarily true. It’s complicated and long and I won’t go into my full opinion or anything so I don’t start going off on a tangent/rambling again but the vast majority of breeders (AKC, UKC, etc.) do not sterilize dogs before rehoming. They simply have a spay/neuter contract which seems to work well. Also, a lot of other countries don’t even fix dogs or fix them a lot less often and they don’t have that many more unwanted litters or behavior problems. I think the key is management rather than just always fixing the dog. It is not that hard to manage intact dogs if the time and effort is put in. BUT. For the average pet owner, fixing is probably best, but I don’t think it should be done so young. For shelters rehoming older dogs, I think they should all be fixed if they’re above like 6 months.
  • I was simply using the term the breeders listed on their websites. I don’t know if it’s right or not but it probably doesn’t matter much anyway. Also I think in Australia and the UK they call it desexing and the breed originated in Australia.
  • 6 months is not that early and I wasn’t saying they’d be under or over weight or height. Most dogs are fine. BUT...
  • They DO still need their hormones. Yes they can look and appear healthy and fine, was not saying they would drop dead or get sickly or something, but there is actually a lot of research out now saying that early spaying and neutering is really bad for large breed dogs and can cause a lot of health problems. They are a lot more prone to ACL/tendon/ligament injuries and structure issues. Spayed and neutered dogs also tend to be taller and lankier than their intact relatives. They need the hormones to close the growth plates properly. If they are neutered too early, the growth plates won’t close on time and they will continue to grow. This is why they are also more prone to the ACL injuries because they are taller than they “should be.” Large breed dogs shouldn’t be fixed until AT LEAST 1 year, for most of the giant breeds it is 18 months to 2 years. In fact, a lot of breeders of giant breeds have it in their contracts not to neuter until that age. Even some Golden breeders have it in their contracts now. There is a lot of research about the potential joint issues and ACL issues for me to ever risk it. Certain breeds are also more prone to cancers and there is even one vet that says dogs shouldn’t be fixed at all or at least put on hormone supplements because all their fixed clients ended up with endocrine issues. I am not that extreme but there is enough research that I will either not fix my next dog or I will do an alternative, hormone sparing surgery like the ovary sparing spay for females or vasectomy for males. I won’t risk it. We neutered Gator way too early and he has had numerous leg injuries and health issues. Cattle, cats, and dogs are all completely different species and early spaying and neutering of cats generally does not have the same ramifications as it does on dogs. And cattle usually only stay alive a few years anyway so if there were any consequences, we probably wouldn’t know. And the issue is not whether they reach full size or not. It is joint and muscle health.
  • I know they are not purebred. I was not trying to say that they were and I know that there are lots of fake registries established by puppy mills. But my point was that the Australian Labradoodle is a specific type that has been bred for over 30 years and they have strict requirements about what qualifies as one and who can be registered as one as well as their temperament and coat type, etc. and some of the breeders have been breeding 10 years, 20 years, etc. just like most purebreds, so they are more reputable than most of the other doodles and mutts. And all breeds started out as mutts. Registration and breeding true doesn’t happen overnight. They are trying to be established.
  • I know they can go that high but around here they usually aren’t. The really good, reputable breeders are usually around $1800-$2000, sometimes $1500 or $1200 or occasionally more, I’ve seen a few higher ones (over $2000) but it’s not as common. And they’re usually not less than $1000, unless they’re from BYBs. So I know how high a reputable breeder’s dogs can be but my point was that is really high for a glorified mutt. Not that it is high for a reputable purebred breeder. Also, if they are charging more based on gender or a color, especially marking “rare” colors way up, that is usually a red flag and not a sign of a reputable breeder.
  • I get that and I’m not against a deposit but for a lot of breeders it’s like $150 or $200, not $500.



I’m so sorry. :hit :hugs
Thank you for addressing my points :)
Sorry I went off on a tangent. I can get heated about this. Like I mentioned earlier, I've dealt with irresponsible owners dumping pregnant animals.
I am pro breeding endangered breeds, service dogs and work dogs such as police dogs or search and rescue.
Show.... mmmm... I probably don't understand enough to get with the program.
 
Early neutering of large breed dogs can lead to growth issues. Male dogs of breeds prone to hip dysplasia and other joint problems are often neutered around 2 years old as they do indeed need certain sex hormones to properly fill out.
Yes!!! This! 100% THIS!
We spayed our rescue lab mix Venus and neutered Ruger our English Mastiff much too early, at the vet’s recommendations, but Venus has bad hips at 9 years old, and Ruger is freaks me out some days when he trips. Granted this was before the new research studies came out. Now we won’t fix any future dogs until 18-26 months, moreso towards the latter due to the necessity of the sex hormones to steady out their growth and close the plates.

In horses it is also recommended that colts are not gelded until at least a year, many want to extend it to 18 months or more. This reduces the chances of early onset arthritis because the last horse leg joints do not close until well over a year old, as well as decreases heavy smegma buildup due to the reduced ability for them to drop their penis.
 
2 years! :th
I sure hope owners are responsible enough to keep them from breeding.

I don't trust people who don't sterilize dogs or cats they don't intend to breed.
Most people who read these studies are likely to keep their dogs from breeding. It’s not that hard. I know it isn’t because we have bulldogs, who are both still intact because we will be breeding them later on, and when our female goes into heat we make sure they don’t even remotely get interested. She wears protective gear to keep our floors, and herself safe from her heat. They are kennelled and kept a safe distance away from each other when kennelled.

The reason shelters are full of dogs is because people aren’t going to them. They don’t want to “support kill shelters” when most kill shelters don’t have a choice. They’re run by the municipality, and whenever someone is surrendering or they get a call, they HAVE to make room. So until they get the support they need, dogs and cats, will always be overfilling their shelters.
 
Most people who read these studies are likely to keep their dogs from breeding. It’s not that hard. I know it isn’t because we have bulldogs, who are both still intact because we will be breeding them later on, and when our female goes into heat we make sure they don’t even remotely get interested. She wears protective gear to keep our floors, and herself safe from her heat. They are kennelled and kept a safe distance away from each other when kennelled.

The reason shelters are full of dogs is because people aren’t going to them. They don’t want to “support kill shelters” when most kill shelters don’t have a choice. They’re run by the municipality, and whenever someone is surrendering or they get a call, they HAVE to make room. So until they get the support they need, dogs and cats, will always be overfilling their shelters.
Yep. There’s a very sad misunderstanding regarding kill shelters when in reality it is often the no-kill shelters that hoard money and never end up placing the dogs that rot in their “rescue.”

I personally will never breed a dog for as long as I live due to personal morals, but before my Goldens were fixed it was really not difficult to keep them separated during her cycles. The solution to overpopulation isn’t mandatory desexing (which is a real term), although I fully support making it commonplace especially for the average family dog. What we really need is proper education in the USA regarding responsible animal ownership.
 
Last edited:
I tried to follow this as best as I could.
  • Responsible breeders don't sell intact dogs to avoid adding to the already problematic overpopulation.
  • Desexing is an incorrect term. A spayed female is still a female. The correct term is sterilization.
  • My female dogs were spayed at 6 months ON THE DAY and are perfectly normal size and weight.
  • Dogs can get spayed as early as 2 months and be FINE. After two months the reproductive hormones are no longer necessary to their growth. FYI, cattle are castrated at 2 months and still grow to full potential. So are cats.
  • Labradoodles are not purebred, no matter the registry
  • My PUREBRED Siberian Husky female dogs were, at full price, worth $2500 each. That is average price for registered dogs, especially females, and even more especially of rarer colors.
  • The pricey early deposits are to drive off impulsive, irresponsible future owners. PetWorld does the same thing for kittens, selling them at $250 a piece.
Cy, your first point is an erroneous generalization. Reputable breeders do sell intact dogs and bitches to reputable owners with either a contract to spay/neuter the pet quality pup or an agreement for show.
Point two...de-sexing is correct terminology...as is sterilization.
Point three and four...age of spaying at 6 months is encouraged by the idea that it is best to stop indescriminate breedings...an idea promoted in the 80s and 90s by vets, spay clinics, etc. It is an easier surgical procedure at 6 months...according to vet friends.
Now research indicates it should be delayed in large breeds for growth, disease prevention, and health. Smaller breeds mature more quickly and spaying can be done before the first heat cycle.
Our adopted Rhodesian Ridgeback was spayed at four months. Her growth plates did not terminate on schedule. Ruby is 3 inches taller than the female height range and has extremely long legs that are already beginning to show arthritis at 4 years of age.
We held spaying Lily, our RR/lab cross until she finished her first heat (keeping her separate from contact with an intact male) until 14 months. She will be protected from a high % of mammary cancer, etc because we waited.
Our dog Red, a Catahoula/lab, is now 12 and suffers from hip dysplasia and severe arthritis because one is hereditary and the other condition because his joints grew at unnatural rates. He was neutered at 5.5 months on the recommendation by our vet.
Bulls are castrated around two months to 6 months to reduce fighting over heifers in closely packed feed yards and to insure that weight gain is consistent in those steers.
Your last three points I will leave to others to address.

Just home from the vet. We put old Fatso to sleep.
:hit
Kiki, I'm so sorry for your loss. You made the necessary but hard decision because you cared for your pet.

Early neutering of large breed dogs can lead to growth issues. Male dogs of breeds prone to hip dysplasia and other joint problems are often neutered around 2 years old as they do indeed need certain sex hormones to properly fill out.
Amen. I have a list of 25 or more studies that I read in deciding when to spay Lily. I shared a few specific articles with our new vet and she agreed with them and concurred with my request to wait.

2 years! :th
I sure hope owners are responsible enough to keep them from breeding.

I don't trust people who don't sterilize dogs or cats they don't intend to breed.
Responsible owners do take precautions....heat pant don't keep dogs from breeding....they only help keep spotting on furniture to a minimum. Vigilance is necessary...on a leash any time outside. And a watchful eye on her at all times...males can quickly jump a fence to get to a female.
There are many more important reasons to distrust someone than not sterilizing their pets.

There are too many dogs and cats in need of homes to keep adding to the problem by breeding more. Unless you're breeding service or work animals or for conservation.
Education about pet care, insuring pets don't breed is going to help reduce those numbers. Animals are only doing what comes naturally to them.
We the owners must take responsibility for our pets.
Many pet owners who allow pets to breed don't take responsibility for the offspring either. Dumping a pregnant dog or cat or the offspring is cruel. Many animals are dumped in the country or high end neighborhoods using the excuse "because farmers need barncats or guard dogs...or children will convince their parents to allow them to keep it". Sadly animals and offspring become ferel or starve.
Circle back to education!

I'm off my soapbox now.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom