5.5 Week Old Speckled Sussex - Hen?

[Painted Calls]

Pullet for now.

 

[Chickassan]

Looks like the pullet I got from Myers a couple years back.
Her legs seemed thick as a young bird but didn't thicken up much as she grew and are now thin as an adult.

 

[sealskin]

This one is throwing me for a loop. It has a short stubby tail and thick legs, but it is so much darker than the roo I had at this age - way less white on the face and chest. Also my roo had a massive tail at this age and larger comb. Thoughts?

This is the second sussex I've gotten from Meyer hatchery. The last one was supposed to be a girl and it's a boy. Could I possibly have this kind of luck to get two roos when they were both supposed to be hens?

FYI - here was my last roo at the same age here

FYI - this chick ended up being FEMALE