If you think about hens who sneak away to brood a nest, they don't have water and a tray of food available. They just show up one day with a bunch of chicks. I was making the same mistake....providing food and water within two steps distance....then I started noticing that the hens were getting off the nest more frequently and their poops didn't look like broody poops.
Every time I provided close food and water my broodies I didn't have successful hatches....rotten eggs/chicks are just the worst smell ever on this whole Earth!!!! I believe enticing them off the nest that often may have ruined the temps and humidity of my eggs and killed the chicks.
From now on that food is going to be further away and water also. If I start seeing more poop that is less tarry black and stinky, that food will be removed altogether except for maybe once a week.
I think a person can overthink this broody thing and start to worry too much....chickens have been doing this for a very long time without our help.
Every time I provided close food and water my broodies I didn't have successful hatches....rotten eggs/chicks are just the worst smell ever on this whole Earth!!!! I believe enticing them off the nest that often may have ruined the temps and humidity of my eggs and killed the chicks.
From now on that food is going to be further away and water also. If I start seeing more poop that is less tarry black and stinky, that food will be removed altogether except for maybe once a week.
I think a person can overthink this broody thing and start to worry too much....chickens have been doing this for a very long time without our help.