American Idol

[True Grit]

I thought the group show in Hollywood was some of the best TV ever. Great job by the producers and great talent. I've never seen a performance like the "guy who sang Georgia", the one in the white shirt. He just turned himself inside out-wonderful. I can't believe I don't even miss Simon but Ellen added nothing last year and I couldn't stand Kara DioGuardi. I'm enjoying Jennifer but last night I thot she was more concerned that "she" didn't tell them the right way than she was with how they actually felt and what they were going to do now.

 

[SundownWaterfowl]

I liked John Wayne Schulz, too bad they didnt put him through.

 

[sourland]

I also liked John Wayne.

 

[jennh]

I also LOVED the black guy who sang "Georgia". And he is so unpretentious!!! I could see him winning the whole shebang!
I think Jennifer, Steven and Randy cut the right people, except I also really liked John Wayne. I think they should have kept him, and got rid of the guy with the weird glasses who was so mean to J C. ( the 15/16 year old chubby boy). He's a cutthroat Not J C, the other one.

JMHO,
Jen

 

[un-named]

I can barely remember anyone from last year. I enjoyed years previous though. This year seems to have alot of talent. gonna be hard to find a favorite.

 

[BarkerChickens]

Quote:
I agree with you 100%!!

 

[halo]

Crazy good talent this year, wow!!! What in the world happened? Last year was just awful, this year might be the deepest year ever. That black fella who just sang, wow!!!!!!

 

[Robin'sBrood]

Casey and James are two of my favorite guys. Also, Brett, the guy with the round glasses, and the guy who sang Maggie May tonight. And this is just the guys... the talent this year is simply AMAZING! Scotty the country singer is from a town very close to me but I wouldn't vote for him based on that (if I voted, which I don't). To me AI is a TALENT contest, and votes should not be based on popularity.

 

[Robin'sBrood]

Brett makes me think of Geddy Lee... does anyone else get that when they see him. I think it's the hair, even though he was throwing it around like he was Robert Plant tonight.

 

[jennh]

I

Love love Jacob Lusk! He gave me goosebumps, and brought tears to my eyes. You know if he wins, it will not change him. He is so humble.
I also liked the country singing guy, and also the guy who has tourettes syndrome. Man, can he sing also. But Jacob Lusk's range is UNBELIEVABLE!! From low to high, no falsetto, so crystal clear. And such emotion! Can you tell I really like him ? LOL
Now, I really don't care for the 1st guy with the glasses. I think that stunt he pulled at Hollywood week really ruined it for me. I also don't care for the guy with the red hair.
I hope Jacob wins it.
Is anyone going to vote online this year? That should make it easier!

Jen