I've bought from them twice and gotten birds from someone who purchased from them.
The ones I purchased... a buff laced Polish rooster and some cuckoo Marans pullets, were nice quality and the Marans laid eggs with decent dark coloration.
I ordered white and black Ameraucanas from them this spring. Of the 5 black, the 2 black cockerels grew in red everywhere, so I gave them away. Of the 3 pullets, 1 was blue and does not have any beard or muff. The 2 black pullets appear okay. They shipped 3 of 5 whites I ordered. (They sent me a credit for the 5 whites, saying they had introduced a new rooster and had off colored chicks.) The 3 whites were a very pretty splash pullet, a white cockerel with green legs and a splash cockerel with red in his hackle/saddle feathers (whom I also gave away).
Someone else I knew was ordering and I got them to order me 5 more whites this summer. Out of those 5 whites, I got a white pullet with a normal comb, a white cockerel with red feathering in, a nice pair of splash and a funny colored splash, that is growing in some gold.
I wouldn't recommend the Ameraucanas if you are wanting quality. The birds are nice, just not quite what I had hoped for. I will put all of mine I keep in the EE pen.
But, I have heard good things about them and I am happy with them overall.