hey i could prob call myself a newbie i have only been doing the chicken thing for about a year now and i had a few breeds that i didnt like and quite frankly i killed..... i finally settled on something hardy and dependable.....i was like you and couldnt choose so i picked three i have barred rocks, new hampshire reds, and easter eggers. they are all very hardy things that i tried and failed that might help you is pure ameraucanas, cochins, and silkies. i hope that that helped you in your "quest" (lol) to find the right chicken breed!!!!