I finally caved and gave my persistently broody White Rock pullet a half dozen fertile eggs to hatch. I spent three weeks trying to break her broodiness with zero success, and when I finally tucked the eggs under she was so happy she actually started cooing, which was a refreshing change from her usual growls and puffing up. I'm not thrilled with her choice of locations as the nesting box is in the pen with the rest of her flock, but she flat out refused to be relocated. So...my first natural hatch...I hope!
![]()
I had a broody raise chicks in a pen with the rest of the flock. I marked the eggs I wanted her to hatch. Good thing I did because the other birds kept laying in that nest through the whole period. never mind that they had plenty of empty nest boxes to use. They insisted on using the occupied box.

I removed the unmarked eggs every day or two, whenever I would find her off the nest. Most of the marked eggs hatched. After the chicks were done hatching I had to remove all of the remaining eggs, because that broody was determined to sit on them forever. She finally kicked into active momma mode and did a great job of raising the chicks. I kept them all in the pen with the main flock, but I gave them an open litter box of shavings and bedding material to roost in. Mom slept on the chicks until they were about six weeks old. Then she moved up onto the main roost. The chicks slept in the box for a few more weeks, then gradually moved up to the roost with the big birds.
The biggest problem was keeping the big birds out of the chick feed. I used wire fencing with 2" x 4" openings to corral off a section of the coop/run for the chicks, so they could have their own feed and water in a place where the grownups couldn't steal all their food. The older birds could still get their heads and necks through those 2"x4" openings, so the feed had to be far enough back that the older birds couldn't reach it. It worked out pretty well until the chicks got too big to fit through the openings. By that time they were tall enough to eat out of the big girls' feeder. I switched everyone in the pen to grower/finisher for the duration of the grow out. Just made sure I had lots of oyster shell on hand for the birds who were still laying.
Hope your bird turns out to be a good mom. I'm jealous. Broody-raised chicks are the best!