I just realized I missed your feed back. So we did end up using the Velcro collar. I watched a great video of a very healthy, happy rooster wearing one. He was mating, eating, drinking and keeping his girls in line. Making sure they all got chances to eat. No one was being picked on ect... I felt instead of him in soup we would try this avenue. We all love him. He is great with the kids. I don't have to watch my back. I know there are very strong opinions about this topic. For our family it works ! I'm glad people understand we still consider them/him family. If he is comfortable, why not? As many roosters that are thrown away alive in piles scrambling for life so people can have hens. I feel he has a home with many good qualities. I'm all for the collar!! If it's going to keep the flock safe and not harm him... We are currently looking for more property. He's happy![COLOR=797774]Angie16hearts[/COLOR]
[COLOR=797774]You are definitely right to keep that Rooster. He is a good friend to all of you and his girls and does a good job of protecting them from foes.[/COLOR]
[COLOR=797774]They might even get sick without him, then where would you be. Chickens and Roosters have souls IMHO. Doesn't your husband know that? When you give a Rooster away you are giving him over to a dinner plate rest assured so why do it? [/COLOR]
[COLOR=797774]I have three, Would not give them up for that reason even though they have a tendency to be territorial with their hens which would not be a problem but I have just the 7 hens so the 10% error is not working here at all. The oldest is the kindest and smartest and I rescued him from a pulmonary infection and he was gifted to me.[/COLOR]
[COLOR=797774]He is also possessive but only for his two remaining hens. He does not interfere which I call smart. It might be pecking order in part because the new copper moran is the fightenist, loudest, chronic caller I have ever met. I daily douse him with water to shut him up.[/COLOR]
Angie if you can muffle the coop with insulation, I use hot water heater wrap, or with extra boarding and covering holes that are not for ventilation, or just uncover when you get up, this might do a lot to keeping the boy with his family. You included. I am sending you my positive vibes for a peaceful solution.