As long as you don't have huge temperature spikes, I'd try not to worry.
I've had lots of trouble with thermometers over the years. I finally found two that are very accurate and I now rely on them exclusively. I use one in the incubator and one in the hatcher. I have others but don't trust them.
One is this probe that can be calibrated but comes with a 0.9 F accuracy range.
http://www.thermoworks.com/products/low_cost/rt301wa.html
It's on sale now.
One is the Brinsea spot check.
http://www.brinsea.co.uk/index.php?route=product/product&product_id=106
I tried to get the link to the US site but it must be down now.
The down side of the spot check is that it has a narrow reading range and if it's too high or low it just displays and H or L. So you don't know how far off it is.
When I first got the spot check I thought it didn't work but it was all the other thermometers that were way off. Then I got the Thermoworks one and it agreed to the tenth of a degree with the spot check so now I only trust those two.