Hey Joseph!Watch out for color culling too soon. Colors often come in slowly. The "tannish thing" is a bit, well very, off. The orangey one might reamin to be seen. The picture of the colored pullet is nice. Primary fault is the stippling in her feathers, but depending on what you get for colored cockerels, she's certainly a place to begin. It looks like her type is strong--acknowledging that she is young.
The two cockerels in the first photo should be saved at this point. The Colored color pattern comes in slowly. Also, Coloreds are weak in general, as far as color goes. You might find that you have to spend a few, or even several, seasons breeding to strengthen color trends. Remember that it's fair to estimate that coloreds have been on the brink of extinction for untold decades. They were already a great rarity at the turn of the 20th century. 100 years later, it's sort of a miracle that any exist at all. In 1921, John Henry Robinson, one of the best poultry writers of the first half of the 20th century has this to say about the state of Dorkings:
Outside of the stocks of a few leading exhibitors, most of the Dorkings seen here are comparatively poor or very poor type, more suggestive of beefy, low-set Leghorn type that of typical Dorking. True type, always accompanied by good size, is the most important thing to consider in Dorking competition. [...] In the most popular variety, the Silver Gray, one who has not good typical Dorkings should keep away from shows where the breeders of high repute exhibit. So few of the other varieties are shown that almost anything that will pass for a Dorking can win unless the exhibitor happens to run into one of the small strings of good Colored Dorkings occasinally appearing at a large show. White Dorkings of good size, type, and vigor are rarely seen.
At the current point in history--in all varieties of Dorking--stock is lacking in some pretty "basic" qualities. That colored female might be the beginning of a 10 year project that leeds to some of the best colored Dorkings since WWII.
Cheers,
Joseph
The cockerels you are referring to are mine. I am going to hang on to them for sure. The bird in the first picture is getting some pretty nice color! It was quite the surprise since I was expecting them all to be SG. I think two out of the six I got are actually SG. Guess we'll see. I can't wait to see what he'll look like in a few months. They are growing in SLOW... or I'm being very impatient!

Overall, I'm wanting to keep the roo with the best "block like" shape and size. I'm still looking for another pullet or two to add to the bunch with size and shape. Anyone know of someone in Washington State. (Seattle, Tacoma, Snohomish area?)
Thanks - Amy