I'm still new to this, but I believe darker is what we are after. (and if you look at feathersite, their pictures confirm this) So I'd go with the darker one.
From the Standard:
From the Standard:
COLOR - MALE
COMB, FACE, WATTLES AND EAR-LOBES: Bright red.
BEAK: Dark horn shading to yellow at point.
EYES: Reddish bay.
HEAD: Each feather black with slight reddish brown edging and
reddish brown shafts, tips of feather black.
NECK: Each feather black with slight reddish brown edging and
reddish brown shafts, tips of feathers black.
BACK: Each feather reddish brown with very wide lacing of
lustrous, greenish black.
Saddle - Each feather black with slight reddish brown edging
and reddish brown shafts, tips of feathers black.
TAIL: Main tail - black.
Sickles and lesser sickles - lustrous greenish black.
Coverts - same as the saddle.
WINGS: Bows and coverts - Each feather reddish brown with a
broad lacing of lustrous greenish black.
Primaries - Upper web black, lower web black with a lower
edge of reddish brown.
Secondaries - Upper web black, lower web reddish brown
finely laced with black, showing when closed a reddish brown
wing bay.
BREAST: Each feather reddish brown with a sharply defined
lacing of lustrous greenish black.
BODY AND FLUFF: Black
LEGS AND TOES: Thighs - black.
Shanks and toes - yellow.
UNDERCOLOR OF ALL SECTIONS: Dark slate.
COMB, FACE, WATTLES AND EAR-LOBES: Bright red.
BEAK: Dark horn shading to yellow at point.
EYES: Reddish bay.
HEAD: Each feather black with slight reddish brown edging and
reddish brown shafts, tips of feather black.
NECK: Each feather black with slight reddish brown edging and
reddish brown shafts, tips of feathers black.
BACK: Each feather reddish brown with very wide lacing of
lustrous, greenish black.
Saddle - Each feather black with slight reddish brown edging
and reddish brown shafts, tips of feathers black.
TAIL: Main tail - black.
Sickles and lesser sickles - lustrous greenish black.
Coverts - same as the saddle.
WINGS: Bows and coverts - Each feather reddish brown with a
broad lacing of lustrous greenish black.
Primaries - Upper web black, lower web black with a lower
edge of reddish brown.
Secondaries - Upper web black, lower web reddish brown
finely laced with black, showing when closed a reddish brown
wing bay.
BREAST: Each feather reddish brown with a sharply defined
lacing of lustrous greenish black.
BODY AND FLUFF: Black
LEGS AND TOES: Thighs - black.
Shanks and toes - yellow.
UNDERCOLOR OF ALL SECTIONS: Dark slate.