Gotta say...I would be more in favor of putting the owner out of YOUR misery than the dog...kidding, kidding...I think...
Dogs are not so different from people. They often hold jobs, they have a place as part of the family- I would go into a burning building to save my Tim! They too, are imperfect, make mistakes, and occasionally use bad judgement based on the way they were raised, or human, errr...canine... nature. It isnt fair to shoot the dogs because their owner is stupid. Unfortunately, sitting down and chatting with a dog to explain why what it did was wrong, is most likely not going to be successful. Sometimes, punishment is necessary-and taking away the dogs allowance is not going to have an effect. Like people, dogs have rights, and some of those rights are earned. Tim has earned the right to be loose outside, he respects his boundaries, and were he to violate them, he would lose that freedom. Some may think it is irresponsible to leave him loose, I think he has as much right to be loose in the yard as my kids do! If it were dangerous for them, or I felt they could not be trusted, they would be restricted...just like Tim would. The danger in our situation is quite minimal-we are in a very rural area with no close neighbors, our driveway is a 1/4 mile from the road, I am home 90% of the day, and he outweighs any possible predator by a good 100 pounds. We take reasonable precautions-he is fully vaccinated, wormed and receives regular vet care. We do not own our 12 acres, fencing it is not an option. As I said, if there is threat of storms, he is contained in the house so he will not be terrified into fleeing. He spends the majority of his day sleeping under the dining room table. He is old, arthritic, and has earned our trust. It does not mean nothing bad can happen to him, but if we live our lives, and make our dogs live their lives, in paranoia about every possible bad thing that could happen-no one would find much satisfaction in living! Balance is needed, and so we take reasonable precautions. He has been trained, he has responded...and now, 7 years later, he has made an error. In my book, that is a pretty good run. He has been disciplined and forgiven. Now comes the earning our trust back part-and I have little doubt that he will. Your neighbor might not BE the sort that will go to the trouble of responsibly rehoming his dogs-if he has to get rid of them, he may shoot them himself, or give them away in a free ad, dump them off somewhere, or leave them at a shelter to be euthanized. I do not advocate physically punishing a dog as a general rule, but in this instance, it might very well save their lives, as well as the lives of your chickens. Seems like the lesser of two evils to me.