Have ya'll tried Erie Insurance?
We've had Erie for 20 years now and we've never had any problems with them ever. They are also the cheapest out of all the "major players" that we've found (All State, State Farm, Progressive, Geico..etc...)
I just switched my mom from All State to Erie after my dad died - both her house and her auto - and saved her over $500.00 a year and got her MORE COVERAGE than she had before - amazing.
Our agents have been out to our house - they know its 148 years old, had 3 fireplaces, that we have chickens and a pool - and we're covered.....
I dont understand why if you have a "hobby farm" you wouldnt be covered..that makes no sense whatsoever. Our house is old as dirt and we're covered 100% for all outbuildings and the main structure, including all animals.
Note: we also have our life insurance and auto insurance with them so we receive discounts as well. I believe, with full coverage for 2 vehicles, liability on 2 others *and one is a classic car 69 Dodge Charger*, our RV (all with Gap for the full coveraged ones) we pay $1800.00 a year - and our homeowners insurance is $736.00 a year for $350K on just the house structure, that doesnt include the outbuildings or possessions inside - we're covered for possessions at 75% of the value of the house coverage, so roughly $263K on top of the house. Then we have medical and all the other goodies that go with it that are the highest we can get - our deductibles are: $50.00 for autos and $500.00 for the house.
No one else can touch Erie - we've checked. Might be worth checking into for some of you.... and we've had 2 claims in those 20 years - never an issue and received checks within 10 days for replacement of the items that were stolen.