I've said it before, but I'll say it again.
Bob using the word "Heritage" is what got me interested in Standard Breed Fowl. As Walt stated, the APA has no statement or position at this time on what defines a "heritage" fowl. But if a catchy word or phrase can draw new members to the fancy? I'm all for it.
Bob has said himself he uses the word to trick people into looking at the old time, bred to the SOP type of poultry. And I am proof it works. I am one of those people who has always had chickens. Most all the fowl I ever owned were ordered from those pretty hatchery catalogs. And I never once had a bird grow out to look like those nice shiny pictures. Sorta close, almost, but not like the pictures. Until BYC I had never heard of the APA. ABA, the Standard of Perfection, a chicken show.... none of it. I've had thousands upon thousands of chickens in my life and was never exposed to any of this. BYC is full of a lot of goofy threads and misinformation, but if it wasn't for BYC I personally would never have known the difference in a hatchery chicken and a pure bred chicken.
Like Arielle, I still see a need and place for both hatchery and "Heritage" fowl. It's a fact that 99% of the poultry owners couldn't care less about breeding any type bird to the SOP. They want a pretty bird that will grow fast, lay lots of eggs and that can be replaced cheap in a couple of years when it burns out. This thread is one of those threads that is geared to the other 1% that either have and raise "heritage" fowl or would like to.
Because of Bob getting me interested (or "tricked" if you will) and LOTS of other folks helping me with answers to questions or links to better info like Walt, Bill, Chris, Kathy, Al and several others... I now own some of these old line birds. I also owe a lot to people like Fred, Junior, George, and others who like me are just starting out. I learn from those of you who know and those of us who sometimes make mistakes.
I will say the best advise Bob has given me is to go slow and see what you like before you commit. Just my opinion, but I think if you are going to stick with it and be in that 1% who stay with it for years and really learn to be a breeder and not just a propagator you have to LOVE the breed you are working with.
I'll admit, the experts still talk over my head sometimes about genetics and such, but I listen, I try to do what I feel is the best advise. Occasionally I still think an expert is full of... manure? But I accept they know more than I do, so I'm willing to give it a try. I'm learning. Baby steps, but I'm learning.
So to each and every one of you who have helped me... I'll say what I think each and every day when I sit out in the yard and see those beautiful birds....
THANK YOU!