ME TOOHey Tim, This is great info. It's exactly what us newbies have been asking for. Sure, all the birds are pretty to the ill informed like myself, but these pics. really leave no doubt. This is what I've been waiting for! Thank you!
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
ME TOOHey Tim, This is great info. It's exactly what us newbies have been asking for. Sure, all the birds are pretty to the ill informed like myself, but these pics. really leave no doubt. This is what I've been waiting for! Thank you!
I like the second Neff cockerel maybe because he reminds me of my Neff cocks. I was told by Darlene that her stuff does not cross well with John's. Have you considered maintaining them as separate lines?There is one of these males that is head and shoulders better than the rest.
Wow, that was a super critique Tim!! Thanks SO much! I totally agree with your assessment! I feel good that I am on the right tract.Just from the photos the bottom Neff bird appears to have a better tail. I don't really like the low angle the top bird is holding his tail and it looks a bit narrow. The bottom Neff bird's wings are a bit low but i suspect that is because he is trying to balance on the roost.
I love the tail on the top bird from Darlene. His wings appear a bit low/loose. The bottom bird has better wing carriage, but may be a bit narrow in the head.
Its all about putting the pieces together. For example I will mate females that are a bit narrow in the tail but excellent up front with a male bird with an super wide blown tail. Or vice versa.
The bottom male from John's line is my favorite of the four.
My birds (Light and Buff0 are basically a combination of Neff and Spence/Williams lines combined. The male birds I use in my buffs are more heavily Neff influenced. As a matter of fact I still have a cock bird that is pure Neff. Hes a bit old for much fertility now. I still rely heavily on his sons and grandsons in the breeding pens.
Have you considered crossing the two lines? Sometimes it works, sometimes not. You could do maybe one pen with a male from one line and females from the other. Or one pen from each line and one each crossing males from one line onto females from the other.
Also, don't get too hung up on small stuff like a bird a bit too heavy. ALL of the birds that win are too heavy. Not saying it right, just true. Greg Williams told me Bob Arbuckle told him, "If you can't be better, be BIGGER". That is a heavy dose of opinion, but one I share.
I tend to fixate on combs also. They count very little as far as points go. Remember, its the overall package, there is no such thing as a perfect bird. TYPE is paramount.
Tim
Ooooh! LOVE that 2011 Cockerel!!
I doubt that the chicks you hatched are full brother and sister. It is likely she/he maintains multiple breeding pens.Ooooh! LOVE that 2011 Cockerel!!
ShootI don't want to breed brother to sister
Guess I will see what I get mixing the two lines. If I don't like what I get then I will just have to order more eggs. Darn . . what a shame . . hehe . . . always looking for a reason to hatch more chicks![]()
![]()
All of the Neff chicks were hatched from a trio purchased directly from John Neff by my BYC friend in Michigan. The Hobb's line chicks (according to pictures) look like they came from a larger flock of hens and multiple roosters. I am afraid to breed closely related birds from past experiences hatching chicks from breeders that ended up with hereditary defects. I am a softy and it is terribly upsetting to me when this happensI doubt that the chicks you hatched are full brother and sister. It is likely she/he maintains multiple breeding pens.