So I learned that pigeons only stick with one mate.
In theory, yes. But in practical terms,,,, you can get Casanova grade pigeons in both male and female, and have mixed pigeon families.
And so I want to mate certain ones because I keep getting the same colors. My question is, can I just put two pigeons together and hope that they breed?
If you isolate a pair of pigeons long enough,,, they will breed.
I have heard that they can fight each other and that I should keep them separated but next to each other, but how long until I can put them together?
A male and a female will not fight. They may not get chummy chummy right away, but generally will not fight.
Also, what are the chances of them breeding if they already have one whom they have been breeding with?
Like I wrote above,,,,,, if isolated long enough, they will breed together. I don't know the result if they are again all together in a loft open from isolation.
Fanciers that want certain pigeons to breed use the isolation method. They have multiple cages, and they usually have many pigeons that they are working with. They are the kind of breeders to also keep good track of what they want to achieve.
Many years ago when I was hanging around with
pigeon racers, they kept breeding their fastest males to their fastest females. Hoping to get fast offspring. Their lofts were multi-chambered.
All their pigeons had good homing skills. Any that had poor homing skills did not return to loft, and were not missed. Also, the slower, AKA LOOSER PIGEONS ,,,,, were sold for other purposes.
Post some more info on what you are trying to achieve in your breeding, as well as some pix.

There are many here with plenty of IDEAS, and TIPS to help you out.
WISHING YOU BEST,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, and
