There was a question on why I was disappointed with the Buckeyes I have and where I got them. No one from BYC is guilty of giving me inferior birds!
Our roo is from purchased and shipped hatching eggs. He is a beautiful deep color and we have loved watching him fill out. However, he is rough with the girls, not particularly protective of them, and human aggressive. He also high-steps, like he is not certain the ground is not closer to his body, or that it will not drop out from underneath him (it just might if he flogs me again).
His pullet hatch mate died of internal laying.
Our hens are from Sand Hill, and I suspect but do not know that their original stock is from Duane Urch. However, their color is faded looking and their body size is small and not quite to type. They do not seem to have the "Buckeye" personality we observed in the ones we hatched from eggs.
We hatched some chicks anyway in Feb. One of them just never grew, very strange. It stayed tiny and downy while its hatchmates towered over it and feathered out. Eventually it died at 4 weeks. The rest of the hatch are thriving.
So I am just a little nervous about propagating from our current birds. It seems there are many of much better stock out there, so over the course of this summer we will probably make some changes.
Love the Buckeye breed and want to have some better ones!