We have actual Ameraucana hens. In researching this breed I never read anything about being poor in egg production. Sweet breed.Actual Ameraucana or Easter Eggers? Easter Eggers tend to be decent layers, as long as they get enough protein. True Ameraucana can be very poor, inconsistent layers. True Ameraucana always have a color/variety specified and are a consistent breed. Easter Eggers are frequently sold as Ameraucana, but they aren't really a breed at all. They are more of a landrace or type, and vary widely.