Now I'm confused.I am totally hearing what you are saying, but I paid specifically for these two breeds from known breeders, so I am confused. Are you saying that an Ameraucana and BCM sold an individual could actually somewhere in their gene pool have had something else in their mix, but doesn't present itself and other way?
Ameraucana can be lots of patterns but never heard of one being silver penciled and no way should a BCM be penciled.
Which parent is which pattern? And now I agree pics would help.
Now none of this is making sense. I don't think you have what you think you have.