I agree too. I guess I wasn't very clear. If he is a Hen Slasher, cut his spurs. If he still manages to cut up the hens, send him to the grill.I disagree here; if this cockerel caused these injuries, he needs to go. I do hope, as I said earlier, that he is the 'bad guy' in this story, and that it's not someone else.
I'll add that my roosters, with spurs, do not injure their hens. I trim spurs when they get long and awkward for the bird to get around, so they've been plenty long enough to cause harm if that was intended.
That's been my experience here, which appears to differ from yours.
Mary
