Deciding what to do with roosters

orchardflock

Chirping
Apr 25, 2017
99
43
51
We have two flocks, a bantam flock with 2 roosters and 7 pullets, and a regular flock with 1 rooster, 5 hens and 5 pullets. The 3 roosters and pullets are about 15 weeks old. We are trying to decide what to do with the roosters.

Blackson is a golden seabright and started crowing at about 8 weeks. He's clearly the dominant of the two bantam roosters and he takes good care of his hens, calling them over to eat first and sheparding them into their coop if there is any danger or something goes wrong. He's started mating with the hens, but seems fairly gentle. Our kids can easily handle him and he has never shown any aggressive behavior. We got the bantams for 4-H and he doesn't seem show worthy, but he's neat to look at though and watch.

The second bantam rooster is a silver pencil rock named Heyhey. He's not nearly as attractive as our other two roosters, but maybe he'll get better? He started crowing a few days ago, and also started to try and mate with the hens. There is a tremendous amount of squawking every time he tries and this morning we found a bloody spot on the head of one of our little hens after he mounted her and she screamed. We separated him out for now, but we can't leave him out of the yard over night if we don't want him to get eaten. This is my first time having roosters, so I'm not sure if this is just normal behavior he will outgrow. Pretty much the only advantage of keeping him currently is that if we wanted to have bantam chicks, having rock chicks would make it more likely we would get better egg layers and potential meals than a golden seabright.

20170713_113635 (2).jpg


Rooster #3 is an Aquila named Ebony. He's also 15 weeks old. About 2 weeks ago he injured his leg somehow, and was barely walking. He seems to be slowly recovering now, but stopped crowing when he got hurt and hasn't resumed. What we really wanted was an Easter Egger rooster, but Ebony is very friendly and (at least when healthy) a beautiful bird. We're inclined to keep him unless he continues to act sickly. And then I'm not sure what we will do with him - we wouldn't want to eat him. We want chicks, but Easter Egger chicks would be better.
 
If you want to have chicks hatched from your flock, it's likely that you will end up with an average of 60% cockrels. If you don't want to eat them, do you have an exit plan in place for them? IMO, it's not wise to keep a roo, or hatch eggs, if you are not able to make a realistic exit plan for the extra roos. It's not likely that you will ever find no kill homes for the roos from any given hatch.
 
We would eat the extra roosters. We're thinking seriously about eating Heyhey. Honestly, we were expecting to eat a bunch of roosters this year because 13 of the chicks were straight run. We really lucked out with only 3 roosters, even if they are not the breeds we were hoping for. My husband grew up on a farm raising and butchering all kinds of different animals.
 
I let my chickens hatch their own babies out and I will only keep one regular size roo and one bantam roo in the flock. I have 3 full grown bantam hens and 1 roo.. And then their babies. And I have 6 regular hens and 1 roo with them and then their babies. And one We will be selling or eating. He beats the chickens up to much trying to mate. So We keep him separate right now. We eat or sell all roos we don't need or want. I would pick your best roos out of the bunch and sell or eat the others.
 
Last edited:
You are making the decision that some of those roosters have to go, that is good. It is hard decision to make. However, once I have made it, I start to distance myself from them. I put them in a separate pen, and feed and water them, but do not watch them. It makes it a bit easier.
 
I agree it makes it easier to keep them away. Usually I will decide what roos we will butcher and try to get the job done in the day or day after. Makes it a little easier all the way around. I try to sell as many as I can before butchering them. There are people that could need or want a roo
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom