DH shot a 200 lb uck 2 years ago... he tasted really gamey...
I prefer the young does, they taste not so bad as other deer and arent so dry/tough. Of course, pineapple juice usually takes care of the toughness. I plan to hunt the first few days for a big buck, I was raised that you hunt for a big buck, then take a doe on the last day or so if you havent gotten the buck yet. In the end its about feeding the family, but the competition between DH and I is going to reign supreme.