finnfur
Songster
Kim ,I agree. I simplified it this way . Some breeders have a deeper field to choose from. I don't feel we in this line are in that category. There are only so many of these out there and even some of those people are not single select breeding . The originator is no longer breeding to sell. So I don't want to miss any opportunity of producing "Superboy/gal". However that said I only have five pullets and two Cockerels to work with . We are converting our egg flock to all Dels except a few Delaweggers . Others situation may differ to allow more selection.It is not simple is it? Everyone will have different ideas. It is more than what we see though. The easy part is the seeing what is wrong or right. The hard part is getting all of the right in and wrong out.
I think we have to take in consideration what is behind the bird also. In other words size is an especially big deal if that is the trend, but you guys are getting good sized birds. The offspring will still be variable, so if there is a valuable trait in one that you are short on, it might be advisable to utilize it, or hold onto it. You certainly do not want to lose that trait along the way. What is that saying, "first do no harm."?
I think the key to smart culling is knowing your birds. Knowing their tendencies. If they have a tendency toward a fault, then those faults are more of a problem than otherwise. The family behind the bird has as much influence or more than the individual bird. The most important faults to be concerned with is the ones that you are seeing in your birds and everyone else's. You guys do not want those faults fixed and be stuck with them, or give you a lot of grief along the way.
I started this year thinking that I was going to cull for this or that. I had all kinds of visions in my head, but as I got to know them, I had a much different reality than I had pictured before.
I did not get far into my Catalana project before I realized that if I culled for everything that bothered me, I would have an empty yard. We are not improving or maintaining some pretty birds that we bought from somewhere. We are building something, and to build something we need all of the parts.
I would take those three males, and complimentary mate them to the six females according to what you see. I think it is commendable that you are going to single mate. You could scrap any pairing at any point. You will know who is from who. It did not take me long to decide that I believe in single mating. It is not the only way, but it is hard to argue the advantages.
I would not worry about line breeding yet. You need that individual that makes you smile to base a family on. If you hatch enough, and grow out enough, you will see a couple of those this year. Then you have something to base a couple families off of. The bird does not have to be perfect, it just has to be pretty darn good.
I am kind of in the same place this year. I will be looking for an individual or two that I can build on. If I am that fortunate, things will be a little simpler moving forward.
I am not offering advice, just thoughts and ideas. I do not know anymore than anyone, and am just trying to figure it all out like everyone else. My perspective comes from the challenge of a project myself. If we continue in this hobby, we will have been better off from these experiences. This is not for the faint of heart and will require a lot of hatching.
This is a good bunch here, and I will enjoy watching.
Last edited: