I personally think Easter Eggers are quite skittish. If it's just for pets I would recommend silkies or bantum cochins. Production Red chickens (also call red sex link, cinnimon queen, red star, etc.) are standard breed birds, but in my experience are the most friendly wonderful birds! Our would let our kids pick them up, hand feed them and the likes. They are also amazing egg layers of jumbo brown eggs, so thats nice too.
I will agree that I have had plenty of skittish EE and only a few really calm ones. But I seem to find that across the board. I would probably take a skittish bird over a bully, which lots of reds can become.
I have a production red that was broody raised (supposed to be more skittish), that has really come around is already a GREAT pet at only about 6 months old... which is usually when we find even the friendly birds are teenagers and don't want to be messed with. So hopefully she will just continue to be awesome and not get too confident and bully others. And yes, she lays quite often compared to my other birds.
If eggs are important AT ALL... I would skip Silkies, UNLESS you can confirm that they come from a line that is not overly broody. On top of that, I raise Silkies and they can be just as nasty/flighty as any other bird (they just aren't as capable). It ALWAYS about the individual, ultimately. Some of my girls really enjoy hanging out while others aren't interested at all. A couple will strike fast when you approach and one girls even got the name Blue Mamba. To me they are also a little "special needs". Biggest issue I know of is not being able to get them sexed if you are getting chicks. One of my Silkie hens is actually a great layer... if she didn't go broody all the time.
I here bantam Cochin are super broody as well. I have had a LF Cochin and she was a lot of fun.
Because of reported reproductive (EYP) and longevity issues... I personally would avoid the sex links, too much heart ache. But then again it can happen to any breed and I have also geard of them living 7-8 years.
Orpington are friendly enough to hang around and chat, but don't really enjoy holding/petting in my experience. Generally nice birds to have around. But if feed cost is ever a consideration... they are quite a heavy breed for the amount of eggs they produce. For me though, when it comes to pets of course feed cost is a consideration. But if we are only talking about 3 birds and not 20 then it isn't as crucial. In fact, I wonder how the Salmon Faverolle compare? (mine were all boys) They seemed like they might be good pets, plus cute as ever.
