I dont have any problems eating extra roosters but i get attached to my laying hens. I cant afford to feed nonproductive hens so my solution has been to sell all my laying hens at 2 years when they still are laying well. Someone else gets good laying hens cheap..and with that the decision of whether or not to cull them in a year or two as they slow down laying. I do have a few *pet* hens that are here for their lifetime but i try to keep them to a select few since feed is so expensive.