I'll go with Henry and Rita. I don't see a pink comb, I see yellow. Not different from my 2 Fav pullets at that age. And as I posted earlier, my limited experience with Ideal (one order, only chickens I've ever had) says "may not conform to the color standard". Both of my Salmon Favs are brown splotches, not a smooth light brown shading like Henry's and others' you see here.
If you got a 50%/50% pullet/roo mix in a presumed all pullet order from Ideal I think I should have bought a lottery ticket the same day I got my dozen chicks. They were all supposed to be pullets and they ARE, though I sweated for some time over a few of them.
- One of my Blue-red Cubalayas is a red splash. Apparently that is an expected color in a percentage of the birds based on genetics but as a new chicken person, I was afraid that them being so differently colored meant one was a roo.
- One of the Australorps has been much bigger than the other starting when they were about 3 weeks old. So, OF COURSE, I was afraid one was a roo. The bigger one is my current avatar. I thought she looked all stately but I found the Australorp thread recently and by the book, the curve from beak to tip of tail should be one smooth line. She is too flat looking along the back then the tail is pretty upright. She and the two EEs (which Ideal
insists are Ameraucana) are the biggest birds I have. The Chanteclers, Favs, Anconas and the other Australorp are all about the same size. Then there are the two little Cubalayas. They are about half the size of the big girls though they all hatched the same day.
- One of the Anconas started showing a bigger comb that started to grow a bit and get pink well before the other. Then it got red and started to curve over a bit a couple of weeks before the other, so again, I was breaking a sweat I had a roo. Then the other kicked it into high gear about a week ago and her comb is now probably 25% larger than the first and it was she who was screaming the egg song like Ethel Merman singing "There's no business like show business" and checking out the nest box Sunday (we are still waiting for that egg you were singing about Uwe .....)
Point being, as I have learned here and from limited personal experience, don't judge a factory bird's gender based only on odd coloring or size. Look for the pointy hackle and saddle feathers (I almost sound like I know what the heck I am talking about
so a disclaimer - I have NO idea what a little roo looks like from first hand experience (and I am NOT unhappy about that
)
Bruce