For all you dog trainers...picking a puppy from a litter?

When I was picking Annabell, a new thing for me as an adult since I tend to end up with "reject rescues"... I really pulled off of everything I knew about dogs and training, and way back when as a kid when we were deciding with a breeder which pup would be the next blue ribbon winner.

Luckily there were only 3 to look at. The boy I didn't full with, in this house, the boys only listen to me and my husband ends up not caring much for it. Enter... Logan-Bear the sweetest momma's boy EVER. Since I already have one of those, I narrowed it down to the two girls.

From there, I pulled one from the crate and watched the other. She screamed her head off in anxiety. Put the one back and traded. The first one I held, immediately started looking for a way out of the crate, not saying a word. realized there wasn't a way out, and she sat down and stared. Alright, good sign, she has a brain, but isn't obsessive.

So I pulled her back out, held her on her back like a baby. Didn't care. Tried to bite my ear. I laid her on the floor on her back, struggled a bit but not much. I let her up to wonder off, smacked my hand down on the ground to startle her. She ran back to me. Made the other in the crate jump. So I continued on with the one I had out.

I stood her up like a show dog in as much of a stack as I could get from a wiggling puppy. She stood straight, legs looked good. Nice topline. Not that it matters in this house, but it never hurts to have a well put together dog. And she didn't mind me putting feet where I wanted them and holding her tight by the color.

Next was leash training 101. This will tell you a lot about a dog. Does it sit and freeze and refuse to move? Does it immediately grab the leash and start walking itself? (not so cute if you let that continue until it's 100 lbs!) Does it follow you around and grasp the concept quickly? That's what Annabell did, so I took her home.

Don't get "cute puppy and rainbow butterfly" eyes. Really think about sleepless nights through potty training and crate training... really think about anxiety and how that will manifest itself... in an eaten couch or destroyed crate? I saw my husbands eyes start glossing over when she licked his face. I reminded him that since I work full time, it will fall on him to take her out every 3-4 hours while I'm gone. When she gets the runs from a food switch, it'll be him cleaning it up. He needs to watch where he puts his shoes. He needs to make sure all electrical cords are well hidden. He needs to play with her and make her tired so she sleeps a good chunk of the night.

And then he also needs to work with the two grown dogs so that jealousy doesn't become an issue. Logan is especially sensitive to change. He LOVES puppies and other dogs, but he's an attention hound and lord forbid someone take that away from him. Ricca... she's picky about puppies.

So I had to think about the puppy in terms of not only do I like it... but will Ricca, Logan, husband, and household like it? Annabell is submissive enough for Ricca to not mind her. Independent enough that Logan doesn't see her attached to my hip 24/7. Sweet enough that my husband and my brother LOVE her, and smart enough (yet just the right amount of dumb) that my husband can manage her as well as I can since he's the one home with her all day.

We would not have picked any of them if they didn't look healthy, if the breeder was being pushy, or not proud of their dogs, or other red flags about their origin. Same if we both worked full time. But one of us has time for potty training so we can slowly introduce being away from home, to prevent the worse case separation anxiety. There's a lot of pups who are taken from home, and promptly left alone for 9 hours a day, no easing into it. That's rough on even the sanest puppy.

There's a lot to consider, the household, the breed chosen, the breeder who produced the dog, lot's of variables. Think on it from every angle so that 6 months from then, you're not thinking you made a mistake. Lot's of dogs needing homes because of glossy-eyed impulse mistakes.
 
Just go with your gut. You just kind of know.
wink.png
 
Wow! Great advice from all quarters!
thumbsup.gif


The thing is....I already picked the pups, sort of in a hurry and on the run, which is never good. I think the first one was a real gem. He is calm but playful, smart as a tack to not repeat the same mistake twice and seems of normal inquisitiveness....bold but not too, if you know what I mean. Responds well to correction.

The second gal I chose for my sister, as she has been needing a pup too. I chose that one in a hurry on another day....just grabbed the biggest, prettiest female...but had a moment's concern that her tail was down. Almost between her legs down. After having her a few days I have learned that she definitely wouldn't fit in here but may just be great for my sister, who has no other dogs. I generally like dogs that respond to easy training and are able to read my cues well.

This little girl is a hard head but real smart. But not smart enough to stop getting in trouble for the same thing over and over. Very much into manipulative behaviour and getting her own way~if she does not, she will stay in her little dog house all day and give you dirty looks. Only come out for meals and then goes straight back to her house. Six weeks old and makes it quite plain that she thinks she is in charge and just wants to let you know it.

The third little girl was chosen on the fly also(seems to be a trend here, huh?
tongue.png
What can I say? Life is busy... ). She seems very timid, but approached me well on her own turf with her tail up and wagging. Took her home and she has been very scared. I think she will be smart enough but may lack the personality that I like....a little bold but obedient, willing but quirky at times. Too soon to tell.

I tried the puppy on the back trick last night and pup #1 and #3 passed with flying colors....pup #2 did not. What a shocker.
roll.png


I have the option of taking these pups back if I do not like them....I definitely like the first pup and feel he is a keeper. I'm still debating the third pup but will see how she acts once she has grown accustomed to my place.

The third girl will go to my sister's house and will probably be a big, beautiful specimen of her breed...but will RULE that house!
lol.png
I think that will be okay with my sister, as this dog also loves to cuddle and be sweet when she is getting her own way.
 
It sounds like you've taken a disliking to the second puppy so it may be fairer for both of you to return her. I've never seen a 'manipulative' 6 week old puppy.
 
Then you've never seen this one! Definitely manipulative in her own puppy way.
wink.png
I won't be returning her but I am rehoming her.

If any dog can be manipulative, then a 6 wk. old pup can. I've read in several publications that state a pup's personality traits are set by 4 wks.
 
Like I said, it seems that you already have your mind made up about her. Better for her to find another home.

Incidentally it is really not a good idea to take a puppy home at 6 weeks of age. They may be weaned but they still have much to learn from their mother.
 
Last edited:
Quote:
X2. Plus they are MUCH more likely to be problem biters if they leave the litter at six weeks, and a six-week shot is ineffective so you've got an unvaccinated/unprotected puppy for weeks on end.
 
Don't get yer panties in a wad...she found another home!
wink.png



As for taking them at 6 wks....the mother couldn't feed this large litter and the puppies didn't seem to be getting enough to eat with their current owner.....but I guess I could have left her there to starve so she wouldn't become a biter.
roll.png
 
I have pics of the pups I picked....ha! Say that five times real fast!

Dewley, inquisitive, gentle, loving and playful but mostly calm:

6459_dewley_and_wedding_030.jpg



And Two, the timid, who yawns when she is nervous, but also sweet and calm:

6459_dewley_and_wedding_033.jpg


She is slowly coming around and gaining confidence around us humans. Her experiences here have been very positive and we have tried to keep all contact low key and soothing. I have found she really drops her reserve when she is hungry and is around any food....so we are going to incorporate some dog treats into her confidence training to reinforce her coming out of her shell.
 

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom