My decision was, well, girly. I went to the local farm store, grabbed the brochure that showed what the breeds would look like as adults and what to expect for eggs and used color to decide. Just because they were at the farm store I knew they would be hardy in the area.
I got a few meat birds and the rest were egg layers. I wanted a variety of colors of birds and eggs. The blue-green eggs were at the top of the list (EEs). Big fluffy girls needed to be in there (BO). I loved the red birds (Production Red). The feathered feet were cute and the only ones with feathered feet were bantams. I didn't just get 1 of each. I couldn't if I wanted all of the breeds. I can't have roosters and I was bound to get some. I got 3 of each of the standard size of the egg layers and 2 of the fuzzy footed bantams. 21 chicks came home with me that day.
With having to give some away and eating the roos, we ended up with 4 girls. I didn't get any BO or Red birds, but I did get 2 EEs. I'm happy enough. I'm getting between 3 and 4 eggs a day out of 4 girls. Can't complain! Especially for getting that in Winter in Minnesota! Some day I'd like to get a RIR, BO and a lavander Marans.
Oh, one strange neat thing about getting a variety is that I discovered my BA has feathers that are SO MUCH SOFTER then the other girls!