I would vote for him

Status
Not open for further replies.
Quote:
I would never learn to speak Spanish in our country. Why? Because we are the English speaking country, I will not be force to change my way just for the Latinos, they do not respect us enough to learn English to communicate with us. Instead they expect us to learn Spanish, and put Spanish words with our English words everywhere to communicate with them. If they what to come to the U.S.A in the first place, they will have to learn our culture AND our language, most of them are just to lazy to learn English.

Knowing more than one language is advantageous, and regardless of what country you live in, it is helpful to know the most common languages spoken in your region. Last time I checked, there was no disadvantage to only speaking english in the US, so what are you complaining about? The diversity of other americans? Let me explain why your complaint confuses me: For example, everywhere I go, everything is written in english - and sometimes important things are also translated into spanish. How is that a problem for the english speaker? In my college, 3 semesters of foreign languge (any you desire) are required. I selected spanish, and I really enjoy speaking and understanding it.
I think its unkind to broadly catagorize those who don't speak engish when they emigrate here as lazy. Most immigrants come here as adults, often with limited education in thier own language and end up working at jobs which expose them for the most part to others from thier country, limiting opportunities to learn english. These same people often live in neighborhoods which are commonly populated with other people from thier home country, and also do not speak english. Again, little time or opportunity to be exposed to english in thier non-working hours. I have had to take 3+ semesters of spanish to have even a basic grasp of that language and I had the benefit of quality instruction and a tutor - my husband who is fluent in English and Spanish whose parents immigrated to the US, worked and lived in a spanish speaking community and led productive american lives all without being fluent in english. Thier son, had the benefit of our public school system and a brother who had learned english to make him fluently bilingual. My husbands parents made sure he made perfect grades and never missed a day of school, even though they had a 3rd grade education and limited english skills. My husband, the product of non-english speaking immigrants was valedictorian of his school, attended UC Davis and earned 3 BA's and recently completed a Masters.

I am learning German just for the fun of it. The reason I am tired of Spanish language is because they expect me to understand them, when I am working at a job with them, and I cannot understand them. And they have been here a while, so they should know how to speak English well.
 
Framerboy, I can undestand your perspective on not understanding the language, but I think your expectations of immigrants language abilities are a bit unfair. Did nothing I related to you about my husbands familys experience help you to see the perspective from the immigrants experience? I mean, if you immigrated to the middle east but lived and worked in an english only speaking area, how much of the language would you pick up? Because I was hoping that you might see that it isn't just that they won't or don't want to speak english.

BTW, I know you said they have been around long enough to learn english, but you work with them evvery day and you said you havn't learned spanish either, so the contact at work must not be enough for either party to learn. Probably too busy at work, I would guess.
Anyway, not trying to get into it, just trying to understand why language is such a big deal...Where I live, everyone speaks all sorts of languages...lol
 
Last edited:
Quote:
There is another person like myself out there? Amazing. I have yet to meet (in person) another person of scots/irish descent who is Jewish.
frow.gif
 
Quote:
There is another person like myself out there? Amazing. I have yet to meet (in person) another person of scots/irish descent who is Jewish.
frow.gif


Count me in, too.
smile.png
 
Quote:
I would never learn to speak Spanish in our country. Why? Because we are the English speaking country, I will not be force to change my way just for the Latinos, they do not respect us enough to learn English to communicate with us. Instead they expect us to learn Spanish, and put Spanish words with our English words everywhere to communicate with them. If they what to come to the U.S.A in the first place, they will have to learn our culture AND our language, most of them are just to lazy to learn English.

I don't think it's so much lazy as the fact that they don't really need to learn our language. They have their own communities much like the Asians. they have everything they need within a short distance from their house. Our ancestors needed to learn English to survive. Latinos and Asians do not. Now if they want to get decent wages they have to learn our language. Otherwise there is no real need. Besides when you work 12 hours a day you don't have a lot of extra time.

Knowing Spanish gives you a real advantage in a lot of jobs. Besides what if you get puled over in Az and you don't have your birth certificate. They might ship you down to Mexico and you wouldn't be able to communicate with the people there. You would be in the "Twilight Zone".
 
Last edited:
I don't agree with this guy at all. Instead of pushing all of our ethnic, religious, and political views and differences under the rug to ignore and hide them we should recognize them and celebrate them to an extent. Schools ignore religion but they teach evolution as fact. Something has to change.
 
It is not a question if an immigrant wants to learn to speak English or not, if you come to live and work in this country when you are in public you speak English, or exceptions, what you do at home is your business and I could care less what you speak because I cannot hear you, but in public you speak English period.
 
I completely agree with that statement, there are many grade 12s in my school who can't even speak english because everything is offered to them in their language. How do they expect to get a job after they graduate if they can't speak english (even though they have been in the country for a few years) If you don't want to live like a Canadian (in my case) then why did you move here??
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

New posts New threads Active threads

Back
Top Bottom