Great informative thread. Thank you.
To me, breeder is one of those terms that has reached mythical proportions, but the ideal does not always meet reality. Some breeders know exactly what they are doing, hatch a lot of chicks, cull severely, and produce a lot of top quality chickens. I'd be real happy with their culls, even if they are not perfect. Others buy hatchery chicks, breed them, and sell "purebred" eggs without even having a copy of the SOP. You have a lot of people in between these extremes and with different culling abilities or even different objectives. For example, some people breed Marans to win prizes. Others breed Marans to win prizes and lay dark eggs. There is a big difference in buying from a breeder and buying from a top quality breeder that is breeding to your goals.
Picking a breeder that meets your requirements involves research, not just throwing darts at the yellow pages. The better quality stock you start with, the easier it is to get where you are going.
I have not worked there, but I have no doubt the breeders for the hatcheries cull their flocks. They are not going to breed birds that have obvious genetic flaws. They are going to select breeding stock that conforms as much as possible to the SOP, at least as far as coloring and pattern. Conformation is probably not as important, although it may be considered. They will select for vigorous productive birds that lay a lot of eggs. But they are not going to cull with the same goals as breeders that are culling to win a grand prize. If you want a bird that probably lays a bit more than the breed standard and has the general coloring and pattern of the breed you want, I think hatcheries are a great way to go. Those birds will meet the goals of most of the members on this forum..
To me, breeder is one of those terms that has reached mythical proportions, but the ideal does not always meet reality. Some breeders know exactly what they are doing, hatch a lot of chicks, cull severely, and produce a lot of top quality chickens. I'd be real happy with their culls, even if they are not perfect. Others buy hatchery chicks, breed them, and sell "purebred" eggs without even having a copy of the SOP. You have a lot of people in between these extremes and with different culling abilities or even different objectives. For example, some people breed Marans to win prizes. Others breed Marans to win prizes and lay dark eggs. There is a big difference in buying from a breeder and buying from a top quality breeder that is breeding to your goals.
Picking a breeder that meets your requirements involves research, not just throwing darts at the yellow pages. The better quality stock you start with, the easier it is to get where you are going.
I have not worked there, but I have no doubt the breeders for the hatcheries cull their flocks. They are not going to breed birds that have obvious genetic flaws. They are going to select breeding stock that conforms as much as possible to the SOP, at least as far as coloring and pattern. Conformation is probably not as important, although it may be considered. They will select for vigorous productive birds that lay a lot of eggs. But they are not going to cull with the same goals as breeders that are culling to win a grand prize. If you want a bird that probably lays a bit more than the breed standard and has the general coloring and pattern of the breed you want, I think hatcheries are a great way to go. Those birds will meet the goals of most of the members on this forum..