Just because there is hostility on the Marans FB pages and clubs doesn't mean there is hostility here. I think we do well to not bring that here. We are all amongst friends in this group. 
I do agree that if a line was imported from France and not mixed with American bred lines then it would still be of pure French origin. But you don't enter a Marans in a show as a French Black Copper Marans or what have you. It is entered as a Black Copper Marans. I think the only time people get their jimmies rustled is when people tack the French onto their Marans too loosely just as a marketing ploy. Like here is my pure French Marans... but yet they are willow legged and overmelanized as crap. Yes I have been duped that way in the past before I knew any better.
The reason American bred lines are not considered "French" even though Marans originated in France is because you have no idea what all Joe Blow has bred into his birds. That's the truth.

I do agree that if a line was imported from France and not mixed with American bred lines then it would still be of pure French origin. But you don't enter a Marans in a show as a French Black Copper Marans or what have you. It is entered as a Black Copper Marans. I think the only time people get their jimmies rustled is when people tack the French onto their Marans too loosely just as a marketing ploy. Like here is my pure French Marans... but yet they are willow legged and overmelanized as crap. Yes I have been duped that way in the past before I knew any better.
The reason American bred lines are not considered "French" even though Marans originated in France is because you have no idea what all Joe Blow has bred into his birds. That's the truth.
Last edited: