nice type , nice coppery hackle coming along .
good solid head.
nice long back .
good tail form and angle
deep chest.
nice shanks well feathered a little darker ( she need to have a nice orange eyes to compromise for the leg color )
I like they black free from sheen and mossyness .
I like them both .they are keepers for sure .
chooks man
PS . you have to be aware I m working with a French standard NOT any other standard .
So if you are interested of showing your chooks, than you must fellow to your country standard don t listen to me .