X3It is very difficult to judge them from these pictures.
Roo 1 has
a good orange eye
copper ear tuft
horn colored beak
good coloring over all
he has a long back
he is more rectangular in shape
never worry about leg feathering - your hens will take care of that
looking at your hens this is the cockerel I would pick.... those pullets will need a rooster with good color - they need some hackle color and that will come from the rooster
they also look like they have dark eyes
Roo 2
the pictures make it difficult to judge him but...
he does not have the good coloring of #1
his eye looks dark
he has a dark ear tuft
he looks triangular to me lacking mass/breast
he may be better than these pictures but that is what I see