We also have multiple broodies with eggs so I searched for this scenario on BYC as best I could. Multiple people reported issues from co-brooding, like one hen attacking the chicks that another hen hatched. It sounds like it’s working for CluckNDoodle though. I didn’t want to chance it and needed flock separation for 2 of my three as they were getting bullied, so mine are each separated.
Yeah, one of my hens is still raising her bitties in a box beside the other 3. (Edit: I should say she still sleeps with her bitties in the box beside the other 3, she's all over the yard with them during the day.)
My flock has seen a lot of chicks come and go though and I just put a young pullet in with them and they were unfazed. I have a very docile flock but I've never had this many broodies at once so we shall see...
Last edited: