New varieties within a breed............hmmmmm?
Do new varieties help the breed?
1. in some instances no, they just create mediocrity for which I have no tolerance.
2. new varieties are made only to be admitted to the standard and then bred into mediocrity, again no tolerance.
3. new varieties are made, standarized and lost within a short period of time, inexcusable because it is too dang much work!!!!
4. new varieties are made, standarized and contribute to the breed and increase the variation within the breed by creating another independent gene pool.
In the 1960's a man by the name of Alex Duffy made the Brown Cochin using the best of already standarized breeds. Within a few years he and others had standardized the variety and he began winning shows with his beautiful browns. Sadly, his flock was lost to dogs and he passed shortly thereafter. Other breeders either lost interest or lost the birds due to the decreased pool of breeders and lack of knowledge of how the variety was made. The LF brown cochin is gone...........maybe not.
Point to the question: Keep exacting records of matings whether they produced mistakes or success. Never develop a single line of birds, develop multiple bloodlines from which to increase your gene pool and allow for improvement of the variety. Don't paint yourself in a corner!!! Sell good birds to good breeders so they will be propogated and improved beyond where you have taken them. And, last but not least, TYPE, TYPE, TYPE, if it doesn't look like a cochin then there is no amount of color diversity will disguise the lack of TYPE. Breed for type first and the variety will come in time.
I am of the mind that we need to breed the established varieties; maintaining and improving them while at the same time developing new varieties. Just think what the show halls would look like with only black and white birds. The founding fathers of poultry did it and they expected us to continue in their endeavors.
Respectfully with blessings to each of you,
Bo Garrett
The Garrett Nest Poultry Farm
Garvin, Oklahoma