I *think* the one peeping so loudly is the one rocking. The two pips have not changed. I did risk grabbing the one that pipped a little after midnight out of the bator. Did not want any to hatch and start pecking at it. It was dead. Shrink wrapped - the membrane had pulled so far away from the shell I could tell by the pipped place what had happened. The way it was positioned I had no way to see anything but the beak and breathing so I could not tell it was wrapped until I took it out. I should have done it earlier.