Quote:
I HAVE to comment on this. Marans are literally a brand new breed. Of course, nonsense is going to crop up - constantly - even in lines labelled "Davis". But I am confident that Bev Davis herself would NOT sell birds with such defects although she has NO control what hatches out of the eggs, even her own. Others may choose to continue selling birds from "Davis" lines that show up with such defects and as with ALL things - it is buyer beware.
And one additional comment - bad combs, clean legs, and such are not necessarily the end of the Marans breed as we envision it. Egg colour is the priority for some and, I believe, that is also the bottom line among the French breeders as well. For some, in the almighty persuit of the SOP - egg colour is being ignored.
Aren't we lucky we have forums such as these with threads such as these so people can educate themselves and make decisions about what they can and can't live with.
I, by no means was indicating that Bev herself is knowing or at fault.
I was speaking in terms of some breeders out there that are aware of the issues and continue to breed them and sell them as "pure."
Of course it is buyer beware, but does the seller/breeder lose all responsibility for passing on cross bred Marans when they are aware of or been informed of the faults and issues being produced from their birds? Especially those traits and faults that are obvious signs of another breed being crossed in?
And yes it is great to have such threads and forums out there that these things can be discussed and information made available and where everyone gets along and chats like family and friends. Makes learning something to look forward to.
Kim, I believe that if someone is selling eggs in any breed that has major Faults they should stop selling eggs and stock until they have corrected the Faults. There is no way the seller can just say that the stock is a work in progress and walk away. I am from the old school saying if the stock is not acceptable to me it should not be unloaded on someone else. Correct the faults by culling and improving the stock and then sell eggs if you would like. I know that lots of new chicken people get so disgusted from buying faulty eggs that they leave the chicken hobby for ever not to come back. We have a responsibility to offer up something worth owning.