Quote:
Wynette,
Obviously you didn't read my whole post there. I have no problem with people having their project birds at all. It's when they start to sell, an unfinished product as something, "new, rare, and special", when the "project" is still a project. That's where the "money, greed, and fame" come in. Folks then bite and buy these birds as "Marans", when in all reality, they are MUTTS. Until the projects breed true to type, color, and function for at least several generations, keep them in your backyard. There are a few folks on BYC that have dedicated "projects" that take years to complete, and even then are honest about what may pop up. I'm just finding now, duh I'm a bit slow, that some Marans folks are not quite so dedicated, or honest. Easy peasy!
I am so NOT wanting to stir up trouble here because I very much like and respect both you ladies but when, exactly, is a Marans' "project" finished??? All the crap that continues to show up in the Black Coppers, for example, even from the best lines and best breeders - seems to me a few more decades at least of serious, SERIOUS closed breeding before we can even consider them finished ... and we all know that isn't going to happen.
Goddess, That's the problem. With all the projects and influx of new colors, and then newer folks breeding X to Y and selling them as "Marans", well, you catch my drift. In cases, it does take decades, but in these years of self gratification, folks tend to fudge. If I stay in this breed at all after this year, I will breed only BCMs and Blue Coppers. Until I have in my mind gotten to where I am pleased with my birds, only then will I sell them. Just saying, and that's just me. Like has been said before, "you feed them, they are yours, do what you want", but that won't help the problems at all within the breed as long as they are being sold under this and that name, and as Marans. Not trying to be a burr under any one's saddle, it's just my opinion.
Wynette,
Obviously you didn't read my whole post there. I have no problem with people having their project birds at all. It's when they start to sell, an unfinished product as something, "new, rare, and special", when the "project" is still a project. That's where the "money, greed, and fame" come in. Folks then bite and buy these birds as "Marans", when in all reality, they are MUTTS. Until the projects breed true to type, color, and function for at least several generations, keep them in your backyard. There are a few folks on BYC that have dedicated "projects" that take years to complete, and even then are honest about what may pop up. I'm just finding now, duh I'm a bit slow, that some Marans folks are not quite so dedicated, or honest. Easy peasy!
I am so NOT wanting to stir up trouble here because I very much like and respect both you ladies but when, exactly, is a Marans' "project" finished??? All the crap that continues to show up in the Black Coppers, for example, even from the best lines and best breeders - seems to me a few more decades at least of serious, SERIOUS closed breeding before we can even consider them finished ... and we all know that isn't going to happen.

Goddess, That's the problem. With all the projects and influx of new colors, and then newer folks breeding X to Y and selling them as "Marans", well, you catch my drift. In cases, it does take decades, but in these years of self gratification, folks tend to fudge. If I stay in this breed at all after this year, I will breed only BCMs and Blue Coppers. Until I have in my mind gotten to where I am pleased with my birds, only then will I sell them. Just saying, and that's just me. Like has been said before, "you feed them, they are yours, do what you want", but that won't help the problems at all within the breed as long as they are being sold under this and that name, and as Marans. Not trying to be a burr under any one's saddle, it's just my opinion.