THANK YOU and yes, I want your honest opinion! However, I am not so sure he came from you after all..... I will for sure test mate him LOTS. I 4 more cockerels growing out so (3 are Cottage Hill) and I guess time will tell. This guy may be more work than he is worth :/ ...but no white under fluff at this point which is something I have really struggled with so far!
The males that I grew out ended up having a cinnamon edged primary flight feather. One of the males that my best friend still has (I don't know why she still has him) is completely orange.....I mean orange....TOTALLY ORANGE.
Below is a photo of one of the off colored chicks that I hatched on New Years Day 2012 they came from the same source as your males father originally came from.
Notice the leg color is off and notice the red or cinnamon colored head. I think I had 3 like this in the NYD hatch.
These photos are of the 3 as they began to feather out.
and here is a photo of my friends orange rooster when he was a youngin. Will see if she can email me a photo of him now.
Not saying this is what you are going to get...just sharing so you can see what I experienced with the same bloodline.