Quote:
We're moving away from calling them "French" - the American [proposed] standard calls for feathered shanks, thus...they are American, and non-feather shanked Marans would be disqualified in a show pen. But, many folks, including myself, have called any Marans with feathered shanks a "French" variety.
That brings up a good point or rather question I've been meaning to ask. So what will all the folks with clean legged Marans now call their flock since clean legged will be disqualified as if they are no longer Marans?????
Or, in other words, what language will those of us with the former "French" variety (feathered legs) use to differentiate from the former "American" version (clean legged) and vice versa????
It seems like if everyone is now going to call them simply Black Copper Marans we will forever be having to say "feathered legged" or "clean legged". I guess over time, those with the clean legged, since they won't be able to show them, will just get rid of them. Seems a shame since there are some nice looking clean legged Marans out there.
And everyone - please know I'm just asking what, to me, seems an obvious question that I haven't seen addressed. I mean no harm, ill-will, and certainly don't want to cause trouble and I'm not directing this at anyone in particular - just putting it "out there" for discussion.
It remains to be seen, but the APA versions will only be called Marans...not feather legged Marans. There will always be a market for the eggs because of their color and some folks don't really care about an APA Standard bird. They just want a chicken to cross into their EE's or simply a chicken that can lay a hershy egg, so I think there will always be a place for the birds with clean legs. I would also say that the clean legged birds would be thought of more as British/Australian Marans rather than an "American" Marans. The only Marans I saw as a judge/exhibitor until two years ago were cuckoo clean legged Marans.
Walt
We're moving away from calling them "French" - the American [proposed] standard calls for feathered shanks, thus...they are American, and non-feather shanked Marans would be disqualified in a show pen. But, many folks, including myself, have called any Marans with feathered shanks a "French" variety.
That brings up a good point or rather question I've been meaning to ask. So what will all the folks with clean legged Marans now call their flock since clean legged will be disqualified as if they are no longer Marans?????
Or, in other words, what language will those of us with the former "French" variety (feathered legs) use to differentiate from the former "American" version (clean legged) and vice versa????
It seems like if everyone is now going to call them simply Black Copper Marans we will forever be having to say "feathered legged" or "clean legged". I guess over time, those with the clean legged, since they won't be able to show them, will just get rid of them. Seems a shame since there are some nice looking clean legged Marans out there.
And everyone - please know I'm just asking what, to me, seems an obvious question that I haven't seen addressed. I mean no harm, ill-will, and certainly don't want to cause trouble and I'm not directing this at anyone in particular - just putting it "out there" for discussion.
It remains to be seen, but the APA versions will only be called Marans...not feather legged Marans. There will always be a market for the eggs because of their color and some folks don't really care about an APA Standard bird. They just want a chicken to cross into their EE's or simply a chicken that can lay a hershy egg, so I think there will always be a place for the birds with clean legs. I would also say that the clean legged birds would be thought of more as British/Australian Marans rather than an "American" Marans. The only Marans I saw as a judge/exhibitor until two years ago were cuckoo clean legged Marans.
Walt