Quote:
For me its about the whole bird...if a bird already had something else going that I'm not liking...like they don't measure up to some of the other prospects I have growing out or already in the breeding pen..and they gotta go. Now...if I'm working on a pen that needs work and I have smaller options, I will evaluate a bit differently and say for instance I had two birds that look pretty similar and one has something like a comb defect....and I have only these two to pick from, I will keep the one with the middle toe feathering. This doesn't mean I won't rigorously work on culling for it in successive generations, but sometimes it does come down to what you can and can't live with and what you can deal with and what resources you have already available. In a perfect world...I would cull absolutely everything that doesn't look perfect, but there just isn't such a thing as a perfect bird, so working toward standard takes time and sometimes it means playing it safe and sometimes means taking some risks. This is where careful breeding records and IDing birds is your best friend. It gives some leeway to take these calculated risks, because you always know who is who and if they don't pan out, out they go and on you go without having lost track of who is from who and what is in what line or group and etc.
X2! Well said. I tend to pick and choose my battles when it comes to faults. Can't do away with everything here, or I'd have no birds! DQs that are hard(er) to get rid of go. If I have something I think I may be able to work around, test it and see. It all depends on what irks you the most...for me, it's these awful combs right now.
yup...combs top my list by far. I do not give much leeway at all with them, never have. It serves me well for the most part. There are always issues that can pop up from time to time that were lurking, but this is where being merciless on comb issues will help!
Some things are easier to deal with than others, but as a general rule of thumb... general poultry DQs are often a bit more tenacious and are harder to get rid of...so those are the first to go for sure, like split wing, split tail, squirrel tail, comb issues, etc.