I have had that Jesse line for a long time (first Wades I bought)....I have never had pene combs come up.... Other stuff.... UH OH YA... The yellow leg thing threw me... but that was a problem in that line for sure as it was in several lines early on.... It was a way in the beginning to show you really had Jesse birds... I have had big combs but not any of the pene combs... side sprigs ya.. in every breed with single combs you have that as a possible fault...There are still a couple of closed Jesse flocks out there... I will ask around...
Debbi... You may ask yourself why ppl don't tell where they got bad stock... it isn't a secret pene society...

No one is HIDING anything...(we all secretly have penedesencas hiding in our closets...he he)

I don't have anything to hide for sure... I have hatched my share of pene combs for sure... I know why too...Unless I got the birds from point of import on a closed flock... with no other breeds in the yard... anything is possible... and still... a nieghbors bird can still visit... We DONT know as buyers what we are going to get... and also the genetics that were available... well they were mutts from the get go... We are just a few short years in and just LOOOK where we are... We have come a long way baby...

Unfortunately ppl still tried to make the wheel rounder than it was... that was the pene problem... if one dark layer is good... well lets mix the two (the thinking here)... Penes have died out.. there isn't many good ones in the US to be found... There is a reason... They are some wicked flighty things... It is pretty easy to see the influence they had... As a person who owned both Penes and Early imported marans from most points of import years ago I can tell you that the early birds are nothing like what we have today... Good and bad... Some flocks will be forever in getting rid of the carnation comb... it is prolific... Did one rooster of Jesse's have a carnation Comb influence... I really don't know... In all the hatchings I did from those eggs... and all the subsequent generations I have had from his closed flocks.. I haven't seen it. PPL Crossed them with Barnies and Wellies also
Valentine was probably the most prolific of the impact on the marans aviculture... they were one of the first to mass market marans at a price ppl could afford.. It showed up in egg color among other things.. Those were some of the first crosses I surmise... I had my share of those...all which met with a clear and definite end.. I gave some eggs away in the beginning. (who knew) fortunately the birds were so unredeaming that I doubt anyone kept em... It is easy to believe what ppl tell you when you buy em. this is truly a buyer beware.... The culling in that respect MUST be ruthless (no offense Ruth he he ) The comb isn't the worst of the offenses IMHO.. it is the attitude of the birds also.. They are rangy and the roosters aren't friendly... the eye color isn't right... dark flecks etc...It is also the genetic base. We can get hung up on the combs but there are other signs of
the roosters that have gone before.... The sickle tails and rangey bodies.. that is enough to scrap heap em if you ask me.... the nice short tails and low riding bodies are more in keeping with what the breed is supposed to look like... If we keep that MEAT/EGG producer in mind we won't need to scrutinize the combs so hard as the pene culling will dissappear at a faster rate... There are breeders out there that I wouldn't take their birds even if they were free.... I think of it as poison to my flock... It all comes back to the same thing time after time...
Monique, I love Jesse's flock... nice kind birds with lots of redeeming qualities.. I will take them as I find them... If in the future I ever have a side sprig show up.. I will let you know.. as of yet I haven't... But who knows... anything can happen in chickens...
The combs argument in this group is years old... glad to see we are still kicking
that dog... I sure thought it would be dead by now. Wonderful to see nothing changes around here.

Let's wage war on the flighty birds.. that is something you hear less about... Marans crawl right up in your lap and want to see whacha got... that is the mark of a good marans... If it is flighty.. eat it.. It should run to the pot... that is my official position on that matter...Well guys... Lots to do today... one of the last nice days... See ya around the cyber-farmyard...geebs has left the building