1. Larry in Hawaii

    Larry in Hawaii In the Brooder

    Mar 27, 2015
    Big Island, Hawaii
    Not sure this is the proper place to post this question but here goes. We have 4 grown hens and 1 rooster. I checked for eggs this morning and found what remained of an egg....runny yolk.... this afternoon I checked and once again I found the same result in a different nest. I have the complete run and coop enclosed with wire so I know nothing large is getting in. So my question is, could one or more of the hens be eating the eggs? We only get one or two eggs a day and hate to loose them of course. I have ordered 12 chicks and would like to figure this out long before the new hens join the group. Thanks in advance..


  2. HEChicken

    HEChicken Crowing 8 Years

    Aug 12, 2009
    BuCo, KS
    My Coop
    Yes, hens will eat eggs. However I wouldn't jump to that conclusion too fast. I've been keeping poultry for several decades and have yet to have an egg eater who cracks the eggs open herself in order to eat them. However if an egg is damaged after it is laid - for example if it is cracked and then stepped on or if I drop it - its a free for all. It may be that one of your older hens is laying thin shelled eggs that are cracked after delivery. One thing you can do to test for an egg eater is to place an egg in the coop that you know to be whole and firm. Leave it for a few hours. If you have an egg eater, it will likely be largely gone upon your return.
  3. Ridgerunner

    Ridgerunner Free Ranging 9 Years

    Feb 2, 2009
    Southeast Louisiana
    I have had one hen that would open an egg and eat it, only one hen out of all the ones I’ve had. It is pretty rare but it can happen. When you are dealing with living animals practically anything can happen.

    How thick are the egg shells of the ones that are eaten? As HE mentioned it is perfectly normal for a chicken to eat an egg that is already opened. That’s not an egg eater. The egg eaters are the ones that purposely open an egg to eat it. Not all chickens will eat an opened egg but most will if they are really opened.

    If the egg shells are really thin, it is not that hard for them to get opened. They may crack when laid, a claw may poke a hole in them with a hen walking on them in the nest, or they may be so flimsy they get crushed by her weight. So check your egg shells. If they are really thin, that is probably at least part of your problem.

    It does sound strange that something like that would happen in two different nests in the same day. That means two different hens are laying extremely thin shelled eggs. That’s not likely. It really doesn’t sound right.

    It could be a hen opening the eggs. I don’t know how well that coop is protected, but it is possible a rat or something else is getting in and eating eggs. It’s really hard to keep some critters out of a coop. They really don’t need much of an opening to get in. Even if you leave an egg in there, if the same thing happens then you will still not be sure that it is a chicken or something else. Instead of just leaving an egg in there, you might try putting an egg where the hens can see it and see if one opens it. Be patient with this. I’ve put eggs in front of hens before and they go over and inspect it, even peck it some, but they didn’t open it. They were not egg eaters, just curious. This stuff can be hard.

    If you do have an egg eater, a hen that purposely opens a good egg to eat it, you will get all kinds of recommendations on how to fix the problem. I personally have confidence in only two methods. Either permanently remove that hen from the flock or build roll-out nest boxes so the eggs roll to a place the hen cannot get to them.

BackYard Chickens is proudly sponsored by