I tend to enjoy the hatchery birds I have had the pleasure of raising but now I hatch my own and get fertile eggs from breeders - but I don't care for SOP. I care about productivity first, appearance second. I have seen a lot of the shaming you talked about, I know exactly what you mean. There is a reason for that new thread for the snobby behavior, which is mostly vacant(12 viewers vs 103 viewers for the general breed).
I love genetics, I really enjoy breeding project birds and playing around with basic principals of Mendelian genetics etc but I prefer the atmosphere of the general breed thread. That and hybridizing isn't really a SOP topic.
This is one reason that I purchase chicks from Sandhill Preservation. He tries to stay within the standards, but breeds for productivity and livability. his birds are beautiful.
Genetics is a fascinating subject.
I posted the following on another thread, but it may be fun to share it here.
Here is my ultimate goal for crossbreeding chickens.
Many pure breeds are available, I have a hard time to choose just one. If I did I will not be happy. Maybe that is why I spend so much money on chickens; to see what I really like the most.
I narrowed down what will be the best solution, at least for me.
Here is what I want in a chicken.
1 Large size
2 Good layer (colorful eggs)
3 Good meat bird
4 Good forager
5 Extraordinary health and livability
6 Gentle around people
Minimum aggression between hens
NO MEAN ROOS
7 Calm, not flighty
8 Ability to go broody
9 Good parents
10 No roosting in trees
11 High fertility
12 Variety of color and pattern
Eye candy is VERY important to me
13 Intelligent (for a chicken)
14 Sustainable for hard times is key
15 Roosters to be good flock guardians
16 Roosters who get along (high hopes)
So what to do? Sounds like a miracle bird.
My plan is to start with purebreds that meet some of my criteria.
So far I have -
Marans
Pure Ameraucana
B/B/S Jersey giants
B/B/S langshan
Brahma
Cochin
Swedish Flower Hen
Sulmtaler
Coronation Sussex
Orpington
Rock
Wyandotte
Naked necks
Salmon Faverolles
Crevecouer
Mottled Houdan
Cream Brabanters
Silkies for fun (they were gifts)
These birds were chosen for some very desirable breed traits. I intend to stop there. Even I have a limit LOL. Most are spring chicks, some are a year old.
If I choose the best for breeding, culls for eating, in a few generations, I hope to have some chickens which will meet most of MY requirements.
I will never show a bird, nor sell them as anything but what they will be. Hybrids or mixed breeds if you prefer.
I am not trying to create a BREED. I have read that eventually the chickens will evolve into a hardy landrace. I chose the Swedish Flower Hens and Sulmtaler because that is what they are: hardy, healthy productive chickens.
I hope never to buy another chick. This will be my foundation stock. Big, healthy, colorful chickens that will lay a colorful egg, raise their own chicks, provide tasty meat and be pretty to look at.
No, I do not have a hundred acres or beautiful barns. I do have secure pens and coops. I hope to have a sustainable flock of no more than 50 chickens. Mixed breeds sell readily here.
Anyway, that is my dream.