One of our Maine posters was at TSC last year, and they had a bin that was labeled PBR pullets. She checked the bin, and sure enough, they were all roosters. It's off putting to me to see a bin labeled "red layers" next to a bin labeled "white layers". And then there will be a sign stating that bin A could have any number of the possible 6 breeds listed, same for bin B. If I'm buying a chicken, I want to know what breed I'm buying. I want to know where it came from. Other issue with buying from a feed store: Some bins are open so the public can hang over them, reach in and pick up the chicks. Even though there are signs telling folks not to... you know the entitled folks... the ones that feel that they are exempt from such warnings. Then, there's the unsupervised, or poorly supervised kids. I don't want my stock handled by someone who's wandered in, and may have diseased birds at home. Then, there's the replacement policy. Check with the store before buying any chicks. Last year, I special ordered chicks (the second year in a row) from a local feed store.. The previous year, they gave the 48 hour guarantee, and worked with me when my 3 Dom pullets were roos. Last year, under new management, the chicks were all hypothermic when I got there to pick mine up. There were 2 bulbs, suspended about 3' above chick level, to be shared between 4 bins of chicks. They were all screaming, pig piling under the little bit of available heat, the ones that could were standing on their tip toes to try to reach the heat. Then there were the comatose ones (including 2 of my special order chicks), and the ones that were too sluggish to even try to get to the heat. I asked the manager where the thermometer was. Got a dumb look. I explained that they didn't have enough heat. His response... "they have a red bulb." So, I got my chicks, and was told that there was absolutely NO replacement policy on dead chicks, even my 2 comatose ones. I tucked the weakest one in my shirt pocket, and made a hasty exit with the rest.
Moral of the story, if you order direct from the hatchery, you'll have more control. Chicks coming into the feed store still get shipped from somewhere. If you have any options at all, order direct, split the order with a friend, start 25 chicks and sell some... At least that way, you'll have the 48 hour replacement policy in your favor.