*Please note:* While I really appreciate the added input to this thread, and hope the information will remain useful for other people in a similar situation, this is an older thread, and we actually adopted our new dog 2 1/2 weeks ago and are really enjoying having her in our lives. Please see post #43 for information and pictures of our new dog!
The long and the short: we adopted an adult dog 4 years ago who came with hip dysplasia (not discovered until after he was part of our family). We resolved to give him as great a life as we could but when the quality of life was gone, we would put him to sleep. Sadly, that time has come.
Looking forward, I do want to get another dog, but have quite the list of requirements so I'm looking for suggestions as to what breed (or mix of breed) might be suitable. My family is licensed as a foster family so we've had a succession of dogs spend short amounts of time in the home and know that not just any dog is the perfect dog for us. Our situation is that we have a fenced backyard that CAN contain a dog 24/7 but prefer to have the dog be part of the family as much as possible. Until now, our dog has been essentially an indoor dog except for necessary trips outside and daily walks. So without further ado, here is the list of requirements:
1. Chicken safe (we need to be able to trust dog when outside, and be able to leave him/her for several hours in the event we know we will be gone from the house for awhile)
2. Must be medium sized dog at least. We ride horses 2-3 times a week and would like a dog who not only can keep up with us but who thinks a trip to the barn is "doggy heaven".
3. Prefer not too large a dog (house is not huge and I prefer not to be tripping over dog all the time)
4. Must be either short-haired or a breed that does not require professional grooming. In other words, an "easy keeper".
5. Must be good with cats. Our family now consists of teens and adults and we rarely see small children so I don't see that being an issue, but we DO have a cat.
Now for some "like-to-haves"
1. I would like a dog that alerts to strange sounds, particularly when I am alone at home, but does not bark every time a branch hits the bedroom window
2. No diggers! (been there, done that, it wasn't fun)
3. Must be okay alone for short periods, up to around 5 hours at a time. We have a crate but prefer not to have to crate dog every time we leave the house for a few minutes - that's just extra time getting out the door that gets old after awhile.
I could care less about breed - any old mutt will do. However if you have a particular breed in mind that meets the above, please let me know. It certainly helps to narrow it down when I am looking at classified listings. For example, if you say you think a Border Collie meets all/most of these requirements and I see a Border Collie X looking for a good home, I would feel confident to contact the owner and find out more about their particular dog.
If you've read this far....I do have a few breeds that appeal to me. If you have experience with one or more of them, please let me know how they rate against the above criteria.
1. Standard poodle
2. Border Collie
3. Shar Pei
The long and the short: we adopted an adult dog 4 years ago who came with hip dysplasia (not discovered until after he was part of our family). We resolved to give him as great a life as we could but when the quality of life was gone, we would put him to sleep. Sadly, that time has come.
Looking forward, I do want to get another dog, but have quite the list of requirements so I'm looking for suggestions as to what breed (or mix of breed) might be suitable. My family is licensed as a foster family so we've had a succession of dogs spend short amounts of time in the home and know that not just any dog is the perfect dog for us. Our situation is that we have a fenced backyard that CAN contain a dog 24/7 but prefer to have the dog be part of the family as much as possible. Until now, our dog has been essentially an indoor dog except for necessary trips outside and daily walks. So without further ado, here is the list of requirements:
1. Chicken safe (we need to be able to trust dog when outside, and be able to leave him/her for several hours in the event we know we will be gone from the house for awhile)
2. Must be medium sized dog at least. We ride horses 2-3 times a week and would like a dog who not only can keep up with us but who thinks a trip to the barn is "doggy heaven".
3. Prefer not too large a dog (house is not huge and I prefer not to be tripping over dog all the time)
4. Must be either short-haired or a breed that does not require professional grooming. In other words, an "easy keeper".
5. Must be good with cats. Our family now consists of teens and adults and we rarely see small children so I don't see that being an issue, but we DO have a cat.
Now for some "like-to-haves"
1. I would like a dog that alerts to strange sounds, particularly when I am alone at home, but does not bark every time a branch hits the bedroom window
2. No diggers! (been there, done that, it wasn't fun)
3. Must be okay alone for short periods, up to around 5 hours at a time. We have a crate but prefer not to have to crate dog every time we leave the house for a few minutes - that's just extra time getting out the door that gets old after awhile.
I could care less about breed - any old mutt will do. However if you have a particular breed in mind that meets the above, please let me know. It certainly helps to narrow it down when I am looking at classified listings. For example, if you say you think a Border Collie meets all/most of these requirements and I see a Border Collie X looking for a good home, I would feel confident to contact the owner and find out more about their particular dog.
If you've read this far....I do have a few breeds that appeal to me. If you have experience with one or more of them, please let me know how they rate against the above criteria.
1. Standard poodle
2. Border Collie
3. Shar Pei
Last edited: