Yeah, we just put one down that - in a backyard where he could have been a pet - probably would have lived a long life...my DH is famously quoted, whenever I have a tough flock management decision to make, "Animal Husbandry 101, Kathy, Animal Husbandry 101" ( to which I may or may not have snarkily replied, "I was a theatre major...I never took it!" )Agreed. And it may not even be a matter of can't or won't afford...
In my case, it's simply a matter of my husbandry method. I'm faced with culling Jack, my avatar roo this weekend. Not because he's sick, but b/c he is no longer hitting the mark when he breeds the hens, and he's becoming rough on them. He's a wonderful roo, but... for the good of my flock, it's time for him to go. He's been with me for 4 years, and I've put this off as long as I can justify.