as put before here is my 2 cents- i have marans for my customers, but they are far from my favorite breed. they are flighty like the RIRs and roosters can be overly aggressive. i also find them to be a breed that breaks a lot of eggs. all my marans are French variety, the American variety may be different. if you are looking for a dark egg, i prefer welsummers. my SQ barnevelders also layed dark brown eggs, but that breed (in my experience) is weak (as in illness) and needs a lot of work.I do like orps. Our last two we had were awesome layers. They loved my kids too. I let my girls look at pictures and they picked out the isbars and cream legbars.they like their colors. I've been debating on selling some of ours once things start hatching and coming along. Especially my pogirls, mixes, and later on my pet quality silkies. Ill probably only keep my layers and add marans and olive Eggers for a colorful egg basket.
Numbers play a big role in all of it too. I need enough layers so that I can get enough eggs for us, family, and to sell. But my DH keeps trying to put me on restriction. Haha doesn't work. If this hatch goes well he is in a lot of trouble because I will be getting another incubator and a turner for my styrofoam incubator. Lol ill be on a roll.
my top layers are Rhode island red, new Hampshire red, black australorps, and turkens. not far behind are Plymouth rocks, dominiques and basque. my white leghorns are probably my worst layers, but they were purchased as show quality, not for laying ability. there is a lot of difference in the 2.