Jeannie - is there any chance that Ms. Cruella is laying what might be considered a "pink" egg? Some EEs lay pink eggs and some lay light blue and some lay green eggs. The closer the egg color is to light blue, the less dilution of the EE gene in the hen, is my understanding.
I took an assortment of pullets and young roos to POOPS that were out of some eggs I got at the NPIP class from TJ's NaNa and Papa Bill - and they were a cross of cinnamon queen hens and EE rooster. I have some EE hens that have muffs and lay a beige egg and some that lay a light blue egg. EEs are my favorite variety for personality, but depending on their origin, their egg color can really vary. Keep in mind however that there are only two true colors of eggs, blue and white. All the brown eggs are actually a white egg with a brown cuticle on the outside. The inside of an Americauna egg will be light blue, even if the outside is green or pink.
I took an assortment of pullets and young roos to POOPS that were out of some eggs I got at the NPIP class from TJ's NaNa and Papa Bill - and they were a cross of cinnamon queen hens and EE rooster. I have some EE hens that have muffs and lay a beige egg and some that lay a light blue egg. EEs are my favorite variety for personality, but depending on their origin, their egg color can really vary. Keep in mind however that there are only two true colors of eggs, blue and white. All the brown eggs are actually a white egg with a brown cuticle on the outside. The inside of an Americauna egg will be light blue, even if the outside is green or pink.