- Thread starter
- #761
Well, I've been thinking about all of this and I think I will stop with the Hogan method for breeding.Selection is the most effective when it is direct. That is not to say that nothing else matters, just that by going in a circle to get back to where you started is not as effective. In short, to select for a larger average egg size, is to set the largest eggs. It is that simple. It is setting a standard for egg size based on what you see, and gradually raising the bar as the average size improves. You will only get as far as the variability within your flock will allow. The more variability, the faster the progress.
The Hogan method is helpful. It is not a breeding method though. It is more of a culling method. I have adapted some of the concepts to the rhythm of the seasons as I select for appropriate type. I agree with selecting for capacity, but all of the capacity in the world does not put eggs in the basket. The most direct way to improve qty. and select the better layers, cull the poorest layers, and select sons of the better layers that prove themselves by their offspring. In other words, his daughters produce better than his brothers when mated with the same females.
All to say, that the most direct way is the most effective way.
I see selecting the width to carry through is about capacity, and fit birds. There does seam to be a correlation on some level to pinched tails, but I evaluate tails by looking at tails. I believe the finish on an otherwise good bird is not complete without an open tail and good tail spread.
So evaluating the fluff, I would focus on it directly by handling them and establishing who has more and less.
I have become skeptical and wary of the round about suggestions, and have come to prefer to break them down into pieces and parts. Then evaluating those parts specifically.
I do not know if any of this makes sense, but that is my two cents. Maybe someone will have something helpful to add.
Got lots to think about as lots is going on and I'm trying to do 15 different things around here besides my birds!
We've started a war recently on the mice on my property! A BB gun is a great tool for taking out a bunch in a matter of a half hour or so. I put out poison traps, drowning traps, regular traps and live catch traps too! Yesterday, we got 17 of the boogers with the bb gun! I HATE MICE!